The incident took place in Putnam County on Monday, Oct. 10, at the Garden Street School in the village of Brewster.
According to the Brewster Police, at this time the three men are just "persons of interest," not suspects.
In addition, there were two other teenage boys that were seen by witnesses leaving the school as smoke was coming out of the second-floor windows, police said.
The two were seen coming out of the east side of the building and fleeing to Oak Street, they added.
Anyone who observed these individuals or has any information should contact Brewster Police Department at 914-804-8442.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Rivertowns and receive free news updates.